|
***** Sword of France Mirrors War and
Peace
"This is a great historical novel
about Napoleon Bonaparte and the people around him during his reign in
France.
By coincidence, I recently read Tolstoy's War and Peace and I kept finding
interesting parallels between the two books. The thing I loved about War and
Peace was the very personal perspective it gave by following very vividly
the lives and experiences of the leading characters. Sword of France does
the same thing and about the same historical events, but from a French
perspective instead of a Russian one so the two books complement each other
brilliantly. War and Peace focusses on the fates of two families (the
Rostovs and the Bolkonskys) during the Napoleonic wars. Sword of France
examines the rise and fall of Napoleon Bonaparte partially in the third
person and partially, in the first person, through the eyes of the French
diplomat and minister Talleyrand.
War and Peace studies the psychology of warfare while Sword of France
examines the psychology of dictatorship and the effect of absolute power on
Bonaparte. The books, naturally, differ in many ways, including length. War
and Peace is monumental in scope and length with about 1,400 pages, while
Sword of France covers the same historical span in a compact 400 pages,
making it very readable. If you like historical novels and want to immerse
yourself in a vivid and absorbing description of the people and events in
France at this important period in European History, I highly recommend
Sword of France."
***** Pleasantly Surprised!
"I was
pleasantly surprised when I started reading the book. To have
Talleyrand narrate the story of Napoleon and Bernadotte was a touch of
genius. It combines three very different personalities who have to
relate to each other for the good of their country. I love a good
physological biography and this one definitely is. Never boring, very
fluid. I'm just sorry that she didn't include the escape from Elba and
the battle of Waterloo. But, as my husband says, it keeps you wanting
for more. I just wonder if it there enough material for a second book.
I enjoyed it inmensely."
**** Psychological Study: Interesting character studies
"Since elementary school, I have been fascinated with Napoleon the
General, Napoleon the Conqueror. My opinions of the people surrounding
him like satellites is always coloured by Napoleon's view of them. I
took for granted his assessment of Talleyrand as a snake-in-the grass,
knowing he had advised and assisted Napoleon's enemies. Likewise, I
considered Bernadotte a Marshal by virtue of his politics, an unlucky
general at best, certainly not in the same league with Napoleon or even
Davout or Ney.
Despite my pre-conceptions against Talleyrand, I found the author's
characterization interesting, entertaining, and believable. Whether it
is accurate, I do not know, not having really studied the man.
I also found his characterization of Napoleon generally quite
believable, although despite all that has been written about the man,
we will always be on the outside looking in, trying to fathom what was
real, what was propaganda, and what derives completely from the eye of
the beholder.
I was least convinced by the author's presentation of Bernadotte. Lest
my scepticism be based on faulty recollections, I read a section of an
old volume on Napoleon's Marshals, available for free on Kindle.
Traditional views on Bernadotte are far more critical and less
admiring, but are likely coloured in the same manner as my own, and are
not necessarily accurate. Likewise, references to Desiree do not match
this authors's presentation.
The author has assembled a reasonable cast of characters and
representation of actual events. Only my own pre-conceptions leave me
partially unconvinced. I recommend this work of fiction expressly for
its unusual vision of the psychologies involved."
***** Fascinating read
"This book
inspired me to go on a reading binge about French history - a subject I
have known little about. I always wondered how Napoleon rose to power
and this book answered my questions. It also gave me a better
understanding of Talleyrand whom history has judged most harshly.
Although superficial in many ways,he was nonetheless a remarkable
person who played a critical role in American and French history and
thus the shape of Europe as a whole."
***** Sword of France
"For European history buffs this is a must read."
|